Pirate Frenemies: When Shipmates Became Enemies on the High Seas
Pirates weren't always loyal shipmates! Discover the famous pirate rivalries, mutinies, and betrayals involving Calico Jack, Charles Vane, Blackbeard, Stede Bonnet, and Benjamin Hornigold.
HIGHLIGHTS: pirate betrayals, pirate mutiny, Calico Jack Rackham, Charles Vane, Blackbeard and Stede Bonnet, Benjamin Hornigold, pirate history, Golden Age of Piracy
They say you should never mix business with friendship. Apparently, nobody told the pirates of the Golden Age.
Imagine spending months aboard a wooden ship with the same crew, sharing food, fighting off enemy vessels, dividing treasure, and trusting one another with your life. You might think that would create some pretty strong friendships.
You would be wrong.
In the world of piracy, friendships could be short-lived, loyalties could change with the wind, and disagreements over leadership, treasure, or a questionable battle plan could turn former shipmates into bitter rivals.
Sometimes the fallout involved a little shouting. Sometimes it involved a mutiny. And occasionally, someone ended up stranded on an island without a ship, a crew, or even a decent explanation.
In honor of National Unfriend Day, we’re looking at some of history’s most memorable pirate falling-outs. These are the stories of captains who lost their crews, colleagues who switched sides, and friends who discovered that sharing a ship didn’t necessarily mean sharing the same interests.
So, grab your spyglass and take a look at the pirates who might have been better off keeping each other off their friend lists.
1. Charles Vane and Calico Jack Rackham: The Ultimate Workplace Takeover
If there were a prize for the most dramatic pirate workplace disagreement, Charles Vane and John Rackham would certainly be contenders.
Charles Vane was an established pirate captain operating around the Caribbean during the early eighteenth century. John Rackham, better known as Calico Jack, served as quartermaster under Vane.
The quartermaster was an important position aboard a pirate ship. He represented the crew’s interests, helped manage provisions and captured goods, and could act as a check on the captain’s authority.
In other words, Rackham wasn’t just another sailor. He was an influential member of the crew.
And eventually, he disagreed with his boss.
In November 1718, Vane’s vessel encountered a French warship. Vane decided that attacking it would be too dangerous and ordered the pirates to withdraw.
Rackham disagreed.
According to the famous account in A General History of the Pyrates, Rackham believed the crew could successfully board the French vessel, despite its greater firepower. Many of the pirates supported him, while Vane and a smaller group believed retreat was the sensible decision.
The ship escaped, but the disagreement wasn’t over.
The following day, the crew turned against Vane. In the traditional account, a vote removed him from command, and Rackham became captain. Vane and the men who supported him were given a smaller vessel, along with provisions and ammunition, and sent on their way.
Imagine being the captain one day and finding yourself out of a job the next because your crew disagreed with your risk assessment!
There is a historical wrinkle worth mentioning: the later account describes a formal vote and Rackham’s election, while surviving trial testimony supports Vane’s removal but does not independently establish every detail of that story.
Either way, the split was real.
Pirate friendship status: Unfollowed, unfriended, and sailing in separate directions.
✨ Step into the world where legend meets history with the Bilge Rat Pirate Adventure Series
— a swashbuckling saga that blends the raw grit of historical detail with the timeless allure of folklore. From cursed islands and whispered superstitions to battles fought under blood-red skies, the series captures the thrill of life on the edge of the map while weaving in echoes of the myths that shaped seafaring culture. Perfect for readers who love historical fiction, nautical adventure, and the folklore of the sea, these tales invite you to escape into lawless frontiers and decide for yourself where history ends and legend begins.
2. Benjamin Hornigold: From Pirate Captain to Pirate Hunter
Sometimes a friendship doesn’t end because of an argument. Sometimes someone simply changes careers.
Benjamin Hornigold was an influential pirate captain based around Nassau in the Bahamas. He was associated with several notable pirates, including Edward Teach, better known as Blackbeard.
Hornigold was an experienced sailor and an important figure in the pirate community. But when the British government offered pirates a royal pardon in the late 1710s, he decided to accept.
That decision changed everything.
Governor Woodes Rogers arrived in the Bahamas in 1718 with the goal of bringing the pirate stronghold under British control. Pirates who accepted the pardon could return to lawful life, while those who refused could face capture and prosecution.
Hornigold not only accepted the pardon but also agreed to work for the government as a pirate hunter.
His new assignment?
Pursue the very people he had once considered colleagues.
Among the pirates targeted by Hornigold were Charles Vane, Stede Bonnet, and other former members of the pirate community.
Think about that career change. One day you’re sharing a drink with fellow pirates in Nassau, and the next you’re sailing under government authority looking for them.
Hornigold’s transformation shows just how complicated pirate loyalties could become when money, survival, and government pardons entered the picture.
He eventually disappeared during a voyage in 1719 when his ship was lost in a hurricane near Mexico.
Pirate friendship status: Changed employers. Now working for the other team.
3. Blackbeard and Stede Bonnet: When Your Friend Steals Your Ship
This might be one of the most entertaining pirate falling-outs in history.
Stede Bonnet, sometimes called the Gentleman Pirate, was an unusual figure among Golden Age pirates.
Unlike many pirates who came from maritime backgrounds, Bonnet was a wealthy landowner from Barbados. He had a comfortable life before turning to piracy, and contemporary accounts suggest that he was not particularly experienced as a sailor.
He eventually acquired a ship, gathered a crew, and began attacking merchant vessels.
It was during this period that he encountered Blackbeard.
The two pirate captains agreed to sail together, and Blackbeard quickly became the more dominant figure in their partnership.
According to historical accounts, Blackbeard decided that Bonnet wasn’t particularly suited to commanding a pirate vessel. Rather than simply parting company, he effectively took over Bonnet’s ship, the Revenge, and kept Bonnet aboard his own flagship, the Queen Anne’s Revenge.
Bonnet was left without his command.
That would be enough to end most friendships, but things got worse.
In 1718, Blackbeard’s fleet ran into trouble along the North Carolina coast. The Queen Anne’s Revenge ran aground at Beaufort Inlet, and Blackbeard eventually abandoned the vessel.
He also abandoned members of his crew, leaving some men stranded on a sandbar.
Bonnet, who had been away seeking a pardon, returned to discover that Blackbeard had taken advantage of the situation and stripped the Revenge of valuable goods.
The relationship was over.
Bonnet returned to piracy, using the alias Captain Thomas and renaming his vessel the Royal James.
He was eventually captured and executed in Charleston in December 1718.
Pirate friendship status: Your friend borrows your ship, takes over your business, and leaves you stranded. Definitely an unfriending situation.
Want to be the first to read Kevin C Smith's blog posts about the real hisotry of the pirates of our past? Sign up for the newsletter join us as we set sail exploring high seas - one pirate adventure at a time!
4. The Pirate Crew That Couldn’t Agree on Anything
Not every pirate rivalry involved two famous captains. Sometimes the biggest disagreements happened among the crew themselves.
Pirate ships were unusual workplaces.
While naval vessels generally operated under strict military hierarchies, many pirate crews developed agreements that gave ordinary sailors a say in how the ship was managed.
Captains could be elected, decisions could be put to a vote, and officers could be removed if the crew believed they were no longer serving its interests.
That didn’t mean pirate ships were peaceful democracies.
Arguments over captured goods, leadership, supplies, and the risks of attacking larger vessels could create serious divisions.
The disagreement between Vane and Rackham is a particularly good example. The crew’s division wasn’t simply a personal argument between two men. It involved different opinions about risk, authority, and what the crew expected from its captain.
In some cases, pirates who disagreed with their leaders left the company. In others, disagreements resulted in mutiny or the removal of a captain.
Imagine trying to run a business where your employees could vote you out of your job and sail away with half the office!
It certainly gave the phrase “team disagreement” a whole new meaning.
5. Not All Pirate Rivalries Were Personal
Of course, pirates didn’t always fall out with their own friends and shipmates. They also competed with other pirate captains for prizes, territory, and reputation.
Piracy was a dangerous business, and successful crews were often competing for the same merchant vessels and valuable cargo.
Two pirate captains might cooperate when it was convenient and become competitors when their interests no longer aligned.
The same was true when governments began offering pardons and recruiting former pirates to help hunt down those who refused to surrender.
The Caribbean pirate community was not one big happy family flying the same flag. It was a complicated collection of crews, captains, alliances, and competing ambitions.
And just like any other competitive business, relationships could change quickly when someone saw an opportunity.
So, Which Pirate Would You Unfriend First?
National Unfriend Day was created by television host Jimmy Kimmel in 2010 as a humorous reminder to clean up those Facebook friend lists and remove people who weren’t really friends.
Pirates didn’t have Facebook, but they certainly understood the concept of cutting ties.
Let’s review our candidates:
| Pirate | Reason for Unfriending |
|---|---|
| Charles Vane | Disagreed with his crew and lost his captaincy |
| Calico Jack Rackham | Took over his captain’s position |
| Benjamin Hornigold | Switched sides and became a pirate hunter |
| Blackbeard | Took over Stede Bonnet’s ship and abandoned his crew |
So, who’s getting removed from your pirate friend list?
The captain who wouldn’t listen? The quartermaster who staged a takeover? The former shipmate who became a pirate hunter? Or the friend who stole your ship?
We suspect the answer might depend on whether you still have your treasure!
Set Sail with the Bilge Rat Pirate Adventurer Series
Friendships, rivalries, daring escapes, and unexpected betrayals are all part of the world of pirate adventure.
In Kevin C. Smith’s Bilge Rat Pirate Adventurer Series, follow William “Echo” Bilge through four novels filled with danger, discovery, and the unpredictable world of life on the high seas.
Whether you’re fascinated by pirate history or simply enjoy a great adventure, there’s plenty to discover.
Four adventures. One complete voyage in the Compilation Book.
Explore the series at Pirate-Tale.com.
Historical sources
These are useful references for the article and for anyone who wants to explore the stories further:
-
A General History of the Pyrates – Captain Charles Vane and His Crew — The early account of Vane and Rackham’s disagreement.
-
Oxford Dictionary of National Biography – John Rackham — Rackham’s career and his role under Vane.
-
Benjamin Hornigold – American Myths, Legends, and Tall Tales — Hornigold’s pardon and transition to pirate hunting.
-
Smithsonian Magazine – The Gentleman Pirate — Blackbeard and Stede Bonnet’s relationship.
-
Library of Congress – Stede Bonnet and the Golden Age of Piracy — Bonnet’s career and the events surrounding his split from Blackbeard.
-
CBS News – Jimmy Kimmel Calls for National Unfriend Day — Background on the modern observance.