A Pirate's Favorite Slice? The Surprising Seafaring History of Pizza
Did pirates eat pizza? Discover the surprising connection between sailors, Naples, Pizza Marinara, and the food of the Golden Age of Piracy.
HIGHLIGHTS:Pizza Marinara history, sailor food, pirate food, history of pizza, Neapolitan pizza, Golden Age of Piracy, maritime food history
What do pirates and pizza have in common?
At first glance, not much. One brings to mind cannon fire, treasure maps, and wooden ships. The other brings to mind melted cheese, tomato sauce, and a delivery driver trying to find your front door.
But there’s a surprisingly legitimate connection between the history of pizza and the world of sailors. In fact, one of the oldest traditional pizzas in Italy has a name that sounds like it belongs aboard a sailing vessel.
It’s called Pizza Marinara.
And no, it doesn’t come with shrimp, anchovies, or a side of buried treasure.
The story takes us to Naples, Italy, where sailors, fishermen, working families, and hungry travelers helped shape the food culture that eventually gave the world one of its favorite meals.
So, in honor of the humble slice, let’s explore the connection between pizza, sailors, and the age of pirates. Just don’t expect to find a pizza oven aboard the Queen Anne’s Revenge.
Before Pizza Delivery: A Brief History of Pizza
People have been eating flatbreads with toppings for thousands of years. Ancient civilizations around the Mediterranean and beyond prepared simple breads with oils, herbs, and other ingredients.
But the pizza we recognize today has a much more specific history.
It developed in Naples, Italy, where flat rounds of dough became an inexpensive and convenient food for ordinary people. By the eighteenth century, tomatoes had become an increasingly popular ingredient in Neapolitan cooking.
This was an important development.
Tomatoes had originally come from the Americas and made their way to Europe following the Columbian exchange. Although Europeans were initially cautious about eating them, tomatoes eventually became a defining ingredient in southern Italian cuisine.
By the early eighteenth century, Neapolitan cooks were using tomatoes to season pizza. The combination of dough, tomato, and simple toppings helped establish the foundation for the familiar pizza we enjoy today.
According to the European Union’s historical documentation for Pizza Napoletana, the earliest version of modern Neapolitan pizza dates to the early eighteenth century, and the famous Marinara was established around 1734.
Naples was becoming a pizza town, and its busy streets and waterfront helped make the food popular.
✨ Step into the world where legend meets history with the Bilge Rat Pirate Adventure Series
— a swashbuckling saga that blends the raw grit of historical detail with the timeless allure of folklore. From cursed islands and whispered superstitions to battles fought under blood-red skies, the series captures the thrill of life on the edge of the map while weaving in echoes of the myths that shaped seafaring culture. Perfect for readers who love historical fiction, nautical adventure, and the folklore of the sea, these tales invite you to escape into lawless frontiers and decide for yourself where history ends and legend begins.
Pizza Marinara: The Original Sailor’s Pizza?
Here’s where the maritime connection gets interesting.
One of Naples’ oldest traditional pizzas is called Pizza Marinara. The word marinara comes from marinaro, meaning sailor or seafarer.
The traditional recipe is surprisingly simple:
-
Tomato
-
Garlic
-
Oregano
-
Extra-virgin olive oil
That’s it!
No mozzarella. No pepperoni. No pineapple. No complicated collection of toppings that requires a second plate just to keep everything from sliding off.
So why the sailor connection?
The traditional story associates Pizza Marinara with fishermen and sailors around Naples. Some accounts connect the name to the fishermen’s wives, who prepared a simple meal for their husbands when they returned from working at sea.
The ingredients were inexpensive, flavorful, and easy to keep on hand. Garlic, oregano, olive oil, and tomatoes could be combined with bread to make a satisfying meal without requiring expensive ingredients.
The pizza became a familiar part of Naples’ working-class food culture.
There is an important distinction here: the historical record supports the pizza’s Neapolitan origins and its traditional association with seafarers, but it does not establish that pirate crews specifically ate it.
Still, when a pizza has a sailor’s name, a maritime backstory, and origins in one of the Mediterranean’s busiest port cities, it deserves a place in our pirate food history!
Naples: A Port City with Plenty of Maritime History
To understand why pizza and sailors became connected, it helps to look at Naples itself.
Located along the Bay of Naples in southern Italy, the city has been an important Mediterranean port for centuries. Its harbor connected merchants, fishermen, sailors, travelers, and ships moving throughout the region.
By the eighteenth century, Naples was one of Europe’s largest cities. Its streets were busy with merchants, laborers, vendors, and people working in the port.
Food needed to be affordable, filling, and convenient.
Pizza fit the bill.
Street vendors sold freshly prepared pizzas to people who needed something quick to eat. Workers could purchase a portion without spending much money or sitting down for a formal meal.
The Smithsonian has highlighted this connection between Naples’ port culture and pizza’s development as an accessible street food.
For sailors coming into port, a hot meal made with fresh ingredients must have been a welcome change from the repetitive provisions carried aboard ships.
And considering what many sailors ate while at sea, it’s easy to understand why.
What Did Pirates Actually Eat?
Before we imagine a pirate crew arguing over whether pineapple belongs on pizza, let’s take a look at what sailors really ate during the Golden Age of Piracy.
Life aboard a sailing ship was not exactly a floating restaurant.
Food needed to last, survive damp conditions, and remain edible during long voyages. Refrigeration didn’t exist, and fresh ingredients were not always available.
Common provisions included:
Ship’s biscuit
Also known as hardtack, ship’s biscuit was a hard, dry bread made from flour and water. It was designed to last much longer than ordinary bread.
It was also famous for being unpleasantly hard. Sailors sometimes soaked it in liquid before eating, and it could become home to insects during storage.
A pirate might have been able to capture a merchant ship, but that didn’t mean he could escape the occasional weevil in his dinner.
Salted meat
Beef and pork were often preserved with salt to extend their shelf life. The meat could be tough and required soaking or cooking before it was eaten.
Dried and salted fish
Fish was another important source of food aboard ships. It could be preserved and stored for longer periods than fresh fish.
Peas, beans, and other dried foods
Dried legumes were useful because they could be stored without refrigeration and cooked when fresh water and suitable cooking conditions were available.
Cheese, onions, and other provisions
Depending on the ship, voyage, and available supplies, crews might also have access to cheese, onions, garlic, vinegar, and other ingredients.
Pirate crews were not all supplied in exactly the same way. Their food depended on the length of the voyage, the ship’s provisions, the climate, and what they could obtain through trade or capture.
A pirate who had recently taken a well-stocked merchant vessel might enjoy a much better meal than one who had been at sea for weeks.
Could Pirates Have Eaten Pizza?
Now for the question we’ve all been waiting for.
Could a pirate have eaten pizza?
Absolutely possible, particularly if that pirate visited Naples or another Italian port where pizza was available.
Pizza Marinara was established in Naples around 1734, during the broader period commonly associated with the Golden Age of Piracy.
Mediterranean pirates, privateers, merchants, and naval vessels operated throughout the region. Ships visited ports where local food could be purchased, prepared, and enjoyed.
A pirate crew stopping in Naples could certainly have encountered the city’s pizza vendors.
But there’s a catch.
We don’t have reliable historical evidence showing that Pizza Marinara was a standard pirate meal or that it was regularly prepared aboard pirate ships.
The traditional Neapolitan pizza also required an oven capable of producing the high temperatures needed to cook it properly. That was much easier to accomplish in a portside bakery or pizzeria than aboard a wooden sailing vessel.
So while a pirate enjoying a slice in Naples is entirely plausible, a pirate chef tossing dough on the deck of a ship is a much less convincing picture.
Unless, of course, he had a particularly unusual galley.
Want to be the first to read Kevin C Smith's blog posts about the real hisotry of the pirates of our past? Sign up for the newsletter join us as we set sail exploring high seas - one pirate adventure at a time!
Why Pizza Was Better on Shore Than at Sea
There was another practical reason pizza was more likely to be enjoyed in port.
Cooking aboard a wooden sailing ship could be difficult and dangerous.
Ships needed designated cooking areas, and open flames had to be carefully managed. Fire was one of the greatest threats to a wooden vessel, especially when the ship carried gunpowder, tar, ropes, sails, and other combustible supplies.
Some ships used brick or iron cooking arrangements designed to contain heat and reduce the risk of fire. Even so, cooking conditions were limited by weather, space, ventilation, and the ship’s movement.
A traditional Neapolitan pizza requires a very hot oven. The wood-fired ovens used by pizza makers were far more practical on land.
That meant a sailor who wanted a proper pizza was better off visiting a harbor town than trying to bake one between the cannons.
And honestly, who wants to chase a runaway pizza across a rolling deck?
The Ingredients That Made Marinara Special
Part of the appeal of Pizza Marinara was its simplicity.
Its ingredients were familiar in Mediterranean cooking and suited to the food culture of Naples.
Tomatoes brought flavor and color. By the eighteenth century, tomatoes had become an important part of southern Italian cooking.
Garlic added a strong flavor and was widely used in Mediterranean dishes.
Oregano provided an aromatic herbal note.
Olive oil brought everything together and helped create a rich, satisfying topping.
The combination didn’t require expensive ingredients or elaborate preparation.
It was a practical food for ordinary people, and its maritime associations made it a particularly fitting discovery for anyone interested in the history of sailors and their meals.
One more fun fact: despite its name, traditional Pizza Marinara contains no seafood.
You would think a pizza named after sailors might include a little fish, but apparently the fishermen were perfectly happy to leave the seafood in the water!
From the Mediterranean to the Modern Pizza Shop
Pizza eventually spread far beyond Naples.
Italian immigrants carried their food traditions to other parts of Europe, North America, and beyond. Over time, pizza developed into countless regional styles and variations.
The simple Neapolitan pie inspired everything from thin-crust pizzas to deep-dish creations, wood-fired specialties, and the familiar takeout pizza that arrives in a cardboard box.
Today, Pizza Marinara remains one of the traditional Neapolitan varieties, recognized for its simple combination of tomato, garlic, oregano, and olive oil.
It is a reminder that some of the world’s most beloved foods began as everyday meals for ordinary people.
And in this case, those ordinary people included the fishermen and working communities of a historic Mediterranean port.
A Slice of History Worth Exploring
So, did pirates eat pizza?
We can’t say for certain that Blackbeard ever enjoyed a slice of Marinara, and there is no evidence that pirate ships carried pizza ovens as standard equipment.
But we can say that pizza has a genuine connection to maritime culture through Naples, its sailors, fishermen, and busy harbor.
The next time you order a pizza, remember that one of its oldest traditional varieties carries a name rooted in the world of seafarers.
And if you happen to be enjoying a Pizza Marinara, you can always imagine a hungry sailor stepping ashore after a long voyage, ready for something a little better than ship’s biscuit.
Just don’t let the captain catch you eating the last slice without sharing.
After all, even pirates have to agree on something!
Set Sail with the Bilge Rat Pirate Adventurer Series
From Mediterranean ports and merchant ships to daring voyages across the high seas, the world of pirate history is full of surprising stories waiting to be discovered.
Join William “Echo” Bilge in Kevin C. Smith’s Bilge Rat Pirate Adventurer Series, where four novels bring the world of pirate adventure to life.
Four adventures. One complete voyage in the Compilation Book.
Historical sources
-
European Union – Traditional Speciality Guaranteed: Pizza Napoletana. Historical background and the 1734 date associated with Pizza Marinara.
-
Smithsonian Magazine – Inside Naples’ World-Famous Pizza Culture. Naples’ street-food and pizza history.
-
Discover Campania – The Pizza. Regional history of Pizza Marinara and its association with fishermen and sailors.
-
Oxford Academic – Underground and Over the Sea: More Community Prophylactics in Europe, 1100–1600. Historical evidence about maritime provisions and sailors’ diets.